We have some clients in CustomerGauge with long tenure. One has 15 years of data, with around 4 million data points. When we fired up Gaige AI and asked some questions, even our CEO Adam was amazed!
This is real data, from a real client with a CX program that has matured beautifully. And these are the two prompts - read through to the end to see some of the real value here! (names anonymised here)
Prompt 1: Go back to the start of the program in 2010. Look at the stats: number sent NPS response close loop. And the top drivers for each year. Give me a summary of this 15 year period and suggest a few next steps - use date_email_sent and average the number of days to close the loop (also what percentage of detractors had a close loop)
15-Year Program Journey Summary (2010-2024)
Volume & Response Performance
Your program has shown remarkable growth and evolution:
Early Years (2010-2015):
- Started modestly with ~17K invitations in 2010, growing to ~121K by 2015
- Response rates were consistently low (8-12%), typical for early CX programs
- NPS grew steadily from 15 to 51 - a strong 36-point improvement
Expansion Phase (2016-2019):
- Massive scale-up: Peak volume of ~484K invitations in 2019
- Response rates improved significantly to 12-17%
- NPS plateaued around 45-48, indicating program maturity challenges
Optimization Era (2020-2024):
- Strategic volume reduction to ~180K invitations (focusing on quality over quantity)
- Breakthrough in engagement: Response rates dropped to 9-14%, but comment rates soared to 53-85%
- NPS excellence: Consistent improvement from 56 to 63 - your highest ever
Close-Loop Performance
Your close-loop program shows limited historical activity:
- Average time to close: 33 days
- Follow-up performance: 75% achieved within threshold (28 days average)
- Critical gap: Close-loop cases were only active in 2014-2015 and 2019-2020, with most recent years showing no detractor follow-up activity
Driver Evolution & Insights
2016-2019 Focus:
- [XXXXX] Adviser dominated (49K responses, NPS 62)
- [XXXXX] Web Site was secondary concern (18K responses, NPS 36)
2020-2024 Transformation:
- Consultant's customer service became #1 driver (16K responses, NPS 89)
- Quality of information provided emerged as key (10K responses, NPS 87)
- Purchase and transfer process shows excellence (NPS 92)
- Service quality themes dominate the top drivers
Key Strategic Insights
✅ Strengths:
- NPS trajectory: 48-point improvement over 15 years (15→63)
- Engagement quality: Comment rates increased 6x (from ~35% to 85%)
- Service excellence: Recent drivers show consistently high NPS (80-90+)
⚠️ Critical Gaps:
- Close-loop abandonment: No detractor follow-up in recent years despite having 1,887 detractors in 2024
- Response rate decline: Dropped from 17.9% (2016) to 9.4% (2024)
Recommended Next Steps
Reactivate Close-Loop Program
- You have 1,887 detractors from 2024 with no follow-up
- Implement systematic detractor outreach within 7-14 days
- Target: 80%+ detractor follow-up rate, <7 days average response time
Response Rate Recovery
- Investigate the 8.5 percentage point drop since 2016
- A/B test email timing, subject lines, and sender optimization
- Consider multi-channel approaches (SMS, in-app, phone)
Leverage Your Service Excellence
- Your recent drivers show 80-90+ NPS scores - use these as competitive differentiators
- Create case studies from your "Purchase and transfer process" (NPS 92)
- Train teams on "Consultant's customer service" best practices
Strategic Volume Optimization
- Your 2020-2024 approach (quality over quantity) is working for NPS
- Consider targeted volume increases in high-performing segments
- Focus on accounts/touchpoints with historically high response rates
Would you like me to dive deeper into any of these areas or help you develop specific action plans for the close-loop reactivation?
We were curious about the way Gaige highlighted the service excellence: "Create case studies from your "Purchase and transfer process" (NPS 92)" - so we made the next prompt about that...
Prompt 2: Drill into the "Purchase and Transfer Process" driver for Promoters. Give some good comments and summarize how we can use for marketing.
Perfect! Now I have excellent data on the "Purchase and transfer process" driver. Let me analyze this for marketing insights.
"Purchase and Transfer Process" Driver Analysis - Marketing Gold Mine
Performance Overview
Your "Purchase and transfer process" driver is a marketing powerhouse:
- 6,324 responses with an exceptional NPS of 92
- 94.4% promoters (5,972 out of 6,324 responses)
- Only 2.5% detractors - this is your strongest competitive differentiator
Standout Customer Testimonials
Ease & Simplicity:
- "Extremely easy to navigate and information provided is supplied at a high level" - [Aaron L, NPS 10]
- "Simple and easy, no hustle" - [Hugh C, NPS 10]
- "It was so easy! For old people that is the main thing" - [Coral B, NPS 10]
- "Very easy process" - [Peter D, NPS 10]
Seamless Transfer Experience:
- "Easy transfer" - [John H, NPS 10]
- "Good that the transfer process is handled for me" - [Kelvin S, NPS 9]
- "This was the most friendly account switching interaction I have had" - [Keith P, NPS 9]
Expert Guidance:
- "Very Polite and courteous and took the time to explain the process clearly" - [Dallas B, NPS 9]
- "Process from start to finish was done with ease! Loved dealing with him" - [Maria L, NPS 10]
Comprehensive Service:
- "Originally, I went on to investigate Private Health options... Allan was EXCEPTIONAL... Within one phone call, he achieved what I was after and had me transferred to a new plan... Allan then transferred me to Jason who helped me with Electricity and Gas" - [Morgan C, NPS 10]
Marketing Strategy Recommendations
1. Lead with "Effortless Switching" Messaging
- Headline: "Switch in Minutes, Not Hours"
- Value Prop: "94% of customers rate our transfer process as effortless"
- Use testimonials emphasizing "easy," "simple," "no hassle"
2. Target Competitor Switchers
- Campaign: "The Switching Experience That Actually Works"
- Highlight Keith P's quote: "Most friendly account switching interaction I have had"
- Position against painful competitor experiences
3. Senior-Friendly Marketing
- Coral B's testimonial is perfect for 55+ demographics
- Messaging: "So easy, even your parents will love it"
- Emphasize human support and clear explanations
4. Cross-Sell Opportunity Campaigns
- Morgan C's story shows perfect cross-sell execution
- Campaign: "One Call, Multiple Savings"
- Promote the seamless handoff between health, energy, and insurance
5. Trust & Expertise Positioning
- Stat: "NPS 92 - customers don't just switch, they rave about it"
- Use Maria L's detailed testimonial for case studies
- Emphasize consultant knowledge and customer service skills
6. Digital Marketing Assets
Create landing pages featuring:
- Video testimonials from customers like Morgan C (detailed success story)
- Before/after savings calculators with transfer timeline
- "Transfer Guarantee" - promise smooth process or money back
7. Sales Enablement
- Train teams to lead with transfer ease, not just savings
- Use Dallas B's feedback to emphasize explanation quality
- Create "transfer confidence" scripts based on these testimonials
Competitive Advantage
Your 92 NPS on purchase/transfer process is likely industry-leading. Most companies struggle with onboarding friction - you've solved it. This should be your primary differentiator in all marketing materials.
Recommended tagline: "Switching Made Simple - 94% of Customers Agree"
Would you like me to help develop specific campaign creative or analyze any other high-performing drivers for additional marketing opportunities?
----------
We love the way Gaige highlighted the marketing message and even suggested a tag line. This saved hours of work sifting through data, and perhaps we wouldn't have event got to the answers. Lots more to uncover, this was just was just a start.
And because we also love our classic dashboards, here is a snapshot of the program charted in Quarters - millions of data points retrieved in 3 seconds!